Allen Brothers vs Porter Road
Cut by cut, per pound.
Both ranches had 8 of the same cuts in stock on our last check. Comparing each one’s cheapest listing per pound, Allen Brothers came out cheaper on 4 and Porter Road on 4.
Same cut, side by side
Each ranch’s cheapest in-stock listing for the cut, per pound. The cheaper one is highlighted.
| Cut | Allen Brothers | Porter Road | Gap per lb |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ribeye | $59.98/lbPrime Tomahawk Ribeye Steak · 1 pc | 30-34 oz ea | $44.00/lbBone-In Ribeye | $15.98 |
| New York strip | $65.42/lb60 Day Dry Aged Prime New York Strip Steak · 2 pcs | 10 - 12 oz ea | $52.95/lbBone-in New York Strip | $12.47 |
| Filet mignon | $39.96/lbChoice Bone-In Filet Mignon · 2 pcs | 10 oz ea | $97.91/lbFilet Mignon | $57.95 |
| Brisket | $13.00/lbPrime Packer Brisket · 1 pc | approx 10 lbs | $15.99/lbBrisket Blend | $2.99 |
| Short ribs | $25.83/lbRosewood Texas Wagyu 3-Bone Plate Shortrib Rack · 1 pc | 5-7 lbs | $16.00/lbKorean Short Ribs | $9.83 |
| Picanha | $35.53/lbPrime Coulotte Picanha Roast · 1 pc | 2.25 lbs | $20.25/lbPicanha | $15.28 |
| Flank & skirt steak | $23.98/lbRosewood Texas Wagyu Flank Steak · 1 pc | 2 - 3 lbs | $27.99/lbFlank Steak | $4.01 |
| Flat iron steak | $34.98/lbPrime Flat Iron Steak · 4 pcs | 8 oz ea | $51.95/lbFlat Iron | $16.97 |
Only at one of them
Only Allen Brothers had sirloin ($27.98/lb), wagyu ground beef ($14.99/lb), lamb chops & rack ($29.60/lb). Only Porter Road had ground beef ($12.99/lb), chuck roast ($19.60/lb), beef liver ($6.99/lb), stew meat ($9.00/lb), burger patties ($13.99/lb), tallow & suet ($14.00/lb), tri-tip ($43.99/lb), oxtail ($18.28/lb), beef heart ($14.68/lb), marrow & soup bones ($14.99/lb).
About the two ranches
Allen Brothers (IL · ships US): we read 156 products from www.allenbrothers.com and priced 32 in-stock listings. Porter Road (Ships in the US): 256 products from www.porterroad.com, 33 in-stock listings priced. Full Allen Brothers review. Full Porter Road review. We may earn a commission from Porter Road; it doesn’t change prices or which ranch wins.
Questions
Is Allen Brothers cheaper than Porter Road?
On our last check it was a tie: Allen Brothers won 4 and Porter Road won 4 of the 8 cuts both had in stock, comparing each ranch’s cheapest listing per pound. Shipping minimums and fees differ, so check your full cart.
Where is the biggest price gap between Allen Brothers and Porter Road?
Filet mignon: Allen Brothers $39.96/lb vs Porter Road $97.91/lb, a gap of $57.95/lb.
Which one labels more products grass-finished?
Allen Brothers had 0 in-stock listings with grass-finished wording and Porter Road had 0. These are the ranches’ own claims, which we don’t certify.
Are shipping costs included?
No. We compare the listed pack price divided by the listed weight. Shipping, tax, minimum orders and membership fees are not included.