Carnivore Club review: is it worth it?
Indiana organ-blend ground beef and steaks, checked per pound.
Carnivore Club sells organ-blend ground beef (its Ancestral Blend and Primal Blend), grass-fed steaks, tallow and a lot of cured meats online. We read its public store every day with 32 other US ranches, so here is every Carnivore Club beef listing we can price per pound, next to the rest. No star ratings, no made-up reviews.
Carnivore Club Ancestral Blend and Primal Blend price per lb
Every in-stock Carnivore Club organ blend on Nov 4, 2026, cheapest per pound first. Bulk packs are priced per pound of the whole pack.
| Listing | Price per lb | Pack price |
|---|---|---|
| Primal Blend Power Pack 20 lb | $11.00/lb | $219.99 |
| Primal Blend Ground Beef | $11.98/lb | $11.99 |
| Ancestral Blend Power Pack | $12.00/lb | $239.99 |
| Primal Blend Ground Beef Family Pack (5 x 1 LB) - High Quality & Flavorful | $13.00/lb | $64.99 |
| Ancestral Blend Ground Beef | $14.94/lb | $14.95 |
| Primal Blend Complete | $15.94/lb | $15.95 |
| Ancestral Blend Complete | $15.94/lb | $15.95 |
Per its listings (Nov 2, 2026), the plain Ancestral Blend and Primal Blend Ground Beef are 90/5/5 (beef, heart, liver); the “Complete” packs are 80/5/5/5/5 and add kidney and spleen.
Carnivore Club vs other organ blends
The cheapest in-stock organ blend at each other ranch we track on Nov 4, 2026. Carnivore Club’s cheapest was $11.00/lb; 1 other ranch was cheaper. Blends differ in organ share, so check the label.
- US Wellness Meats · $9.38/lb · Beef, Ground 55% Lean with Beef Heart - 1 lb
- Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed · $11.42/lb · Grass Fed Renegade Blend Ground Beef with Organs · Case (12 units)
- John Henry's Meats · $12.60/lb · Bulk Ground Beef & Liver · One- 10 lb bag
- White Oak Pastures · $12.98/lb · Grassfed Ground Beef Organ Blend
- Hickory Nut Gap · $13.30/lb · 100% Grassfed Beef Vital Blend with Heart & Liver (10 lbs)
- Force of Nature · $14.98/lb · Grass Fed Beef Ancestral Blend
- Stemple Creek Ranch · $14.99/lb · Primal Blend · 1 Lb Package
- Shirttail Creek Farm · $15.75/lb · Grassfed Caveman Ground Organ Blend (2 Pack)
- Grand View Beef · $15.99/lb · Grass Fed Ancestral Blend Ground Beef
- Parker Pastures · $16.49/lb · Beef Ancestral Blend (1 lb) 10% liver/heart mixed with Ground Beef
All organ blends, ranked: cheapest organ blend. More organ meat prices: organ meats, beef liver, beef heart.
Carnivore Club beef prices vs other ranches, by cut
Carnivore Club’s cheapest in-stock listing for each cut on Nov 4, 2026, against the middle listing across every other ranch we track.
| Cut | Carnivore Club, cheapest | All ranches, middle | All ranches, cheapest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tallow & suet | $8.50/lb100% Grassfed Beef Tallow | $14.00/lb (33) | $5.00/lb, Stemple Creek Ranch |
| Ground beef | $8.99/lbPastured Ground Beef - 1lb | $13.96/lb (107) | $7.25/lb, Joyce Farms |
| Organ blend | $11.00/lbPrimal Blend Power Pack 20 lb | $13.99/lb (24) | $9.38/lb, US Wellness Meats |
| Sirloin | $27.98/lbSirloin Steak (8oz) | $35.39/lb (51) | $19.00/lb, Texas Grassfed Beef |
| New York strip | $52.88/lb100% Grass-Fed Strip Steak | $45.98/lb (54) | $22.98/lb, Snake River Farms |
| Ribeye | $73.91/lb100% Grass-Fed Ribeye Steak | $49.00/lb (77) | $26.46/lb, US Wellness Meats |
10 of its 22 beef listings were sold out on Nov 4, 2026. Every listing is on the Carnivore Club price page; compare it with US Wellness Meats.
Is Carnivore Club grass-fed?
Its organ blends say grass-fed, pasture-raised Indiana beef, and its “100% Grass-Fed” ribeye and strip say grass-fed and grass-finished with no grain at any point. Its plain ground beef and sirloin only say pasture-raised (Nov 2, 2026). For beef that is grass-finished on every listing, see grass-finished beef prices and grass-fed vs grass-finished.
Carnivore Club shipping
Its ground beef listings say free shipping over 150 USD and that orders ship frozen from Indiana in 2 to 3 business days. Its shipping policy (Nov 2, 2026) says orders are processed in 1 to 3 business days and rates are calculated at checkout. Shipping isn’t included in our per-pound prices.
Cheaper alternatives: ranches ranked by price
Ranches that were cheapest cut for cut on Nov 4, 2026 (how the ranking works):
- Joyce Farms · ground beef $7.25/lb
- Home Place Pastures · ground beef $10.00/lb
- Good Ranchers · ground beef $9.60/lb
- Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed · ground beef $8.49/lb
- US Wellness Meats · ground beef $12.13/lb
- Texas Grassfed Beef · ground beef $10.98/lb
Other reviews: Porter Road, Good Ranchers, ButcherBox, Florida Premium Beef, Allen Brothers, US Wellness Meats.
Ranch links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes the order, which is always by price per pound. Disclosure
Questions
Is Carnivore Club worth it?
For organ-blend ground beef, its cheapest packs are below the middle of the market. On Nov 4, 2026 its in-stock organ blends listed at $11.00–$15.94/lb, against a middle of $13.99/lb across 13 other ranches. Its plain pastured ground beef was $8.99/lb (other ranches’ middle: $13.96/lb). Bulk 20 lb packs bring the blend price down. Most of the rest of its store is salami, bacon, sausage and snack sticks, which we don’t compare.
What is Carnivore Club Ancestral Blend?
Ground beef with organ meat mixed in. Per its listings (Nov 2, 2026), the Ancestral Blend Ground Beef is a 90/5/5 blend: 90% pasture-raised Indiana beef from grass-fed cattle, 5% beef heart and 5% beef liver. The “Complete” versions are 80/5/5/5/5: 80% beef plus 5% each of heart, liver, kidney and spleen. In our data on Nov 4, 2026: Ancestral Blend Power Pack $12.00/lb, Ancestral Blend Ground Beef $14.94/lb, Ancestral Blend Complete $15.94/lb.
Is Carnivore Club beef grass-fed?
Partly stated. Its organ-blend listings say the beef is grass-fed and pasture-raised from Indiana, and its “100% Grass-Fed” ribeye and strip say grass-fed and grass-finished, “no grain at any point”. Its plain ground beef and sirloin listings only say pasture-raised Indiana beef, without a grass-finished claim (Nov 2, 2026). We label each listing by its own wording.
Where does Carnivore Club beef come from?
Indiana. Its listings say the beef comes from small Indiana family farms, is processed at a small USDA-inspected facility (several listings name Montgomery Meats), and ships frozen from Indiana in 2 to 3 business days.
Does Carnivore Club have free shipping?
Its ground beef listings say free shipping over 150 USD (Nov 2, 2026). Its shipping policy says orders are processed in 1 to 3 business days and rates are calculated at checkout by location and order size, shipped by UPS, FedEx or USPS.
What are cheaper alternatives to Carnivore Club organ blends?
On Nov 4, 2026, 1 other ranch had an in-stock organ blend below Carnivore Club’s cheapest. The cheapest were US Wellness Meats at $9.38/lb, Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed at $11.42/lb, John Henry's Meats at $12.60/lb. All of them are on our cheapest organ blend page.
Do you earn money from Carnivore Club?
Not today. Carnivore Club links on this page are plain links. We don’t publish star ratings or customer reviews, only prices we can check.
Sources: blend ratios, origin, feed wording and the free-shipping line from Carnivore Club’s product listings; processing and rates from its shipping policy, all read Nov 2, 2026. Per-cut prices are read daily from each store’s public catalog, Carnivore Club included. Methodology.